Eva was on the bed, gulping as she saw a predator in front of her. "What's going on? Why are you acting weird?" She said backing down on the bed.
"I've been feeling horny for days. I don't have any toys. I want sex so bad!" Brenna approached Eva slowly. "Eva, you came here at the right time because you see, if I don't get off I will have done something I'd regret."
"Why didn't you ask Sterling? I'm cool with you having fun with my boyfriend."
"Bitch, he's MY brother. I get to call my rights on him more than you do! But my pride refuses to admit I was wrong."
"Is it about his baby mommy? I don't mind having some fun with her too. She's a looker even with that belly of hers right now." Eva's mind was filled with dirty thoughts. She was distracted by those when Brenna pushed her and went on top of her placing her right hand over her left shoulder.
"Did you just praise her in front of me? Are you trying to replace me, you slut!"
"Oooh, you want to play aggressive?"
"Who says I'm playing!" She grabbed the neck of her top and kissed her roughly. "Mmmmnnn!" Eva was surprised by this version of Brenna. She was filled with pent-up emotions. Eva complied to help her best friend. She held her back wrapping her arms around her. Brenna pulled away and got up removing her skirt as quickly as she could. She pointed at her vagina and said, "Take care of this, you fucking cunt!" Eva crawled on the bed getting closer to Brenna's soaking pussy. While Brenna was standing on her knees leaning back, Eva started licking her. "Mmmmnnn! That's right! My brother tamed you well, didn't he?"
She put her hand on her ponytail acting like she was making her eat her cunt but Eva was doing it willingly for her friend. "You missed this, didn't you? Because I did!"
Eva held her thighs and put her lick deep as she could and flicked inside. "Oooh, is this aaah...fuck that tickles...aaah...you were...ooooh! You were holding onto your tricks, weren't you?" She cummed so hard on her face. Eva tried to drink it but she couldn't get all of it as it sprayed on her face. Brenna leaned back lying on the bed straightening her legs at the same time.
Eva got out of the bed and removed her bottoms. "How long have you been holding onto this much? If I was in your place, I would have hired an escort!"
"You know me...I don't...trust anyone...that easily!" Brenna was gasping as she spread her legs. "I know you came here for him but if you want to be a better wife, you should learn to be a better sister-in-law!"
"Are you sure you're not playing? Is it because you want me to marry your brother before Lisa does?"
"Stop pronouncing her name! She took my baby!" Eva got back on the bed positioning herself between Brenna's legs.
"What are you talking about? That's not your baby!" Eva slowly grabbed her left leg and moved her hip closer to hers.
"I was referring to my baby brother. That girl left him in pieces. Now that she's back, he accepted her like nothing happened!" Brenna moved her hip brushing hers with Eva's.
"Do you expect Sterling to leave a girl in the streets? Moreover, the girl who's the mother of his child."
"No, I would have disowned him...Mmm...start moving!" Brenna yelled at her.
"Then why are you mad?"
"I don't know...just fuck me instead of asking me all these questions!"
Eva moved against her vagina. "Huuuh...it feels good humping you like this." The urge to get to the high ground Brenna made Eva more excited. She increased her speed. "Move your hips, you brother fucking bitch!" She yelled as she ordered Brenna. Brenna gripped her comforter and leaned forward. After getting steady on the bed, both girls ground their womanhood together. "Fuck..! I thought I had you pinned."
"You think you can dominate me! Who gave you permission to insult me!"
"Why am I getting scared when you don't even have your strap-on on?"
"Because of this!" Brenna pushed her against the bed and humped her brains out.
"Fuck I'm cumming!"
"That's right bitch! Cum with me if you want my brother!" Their moves synchronised as the deep orgasms shattered at the same time.
The door opened right after that. "Brenna, is Eva here?"
The women on the bed turned their attention towards the voice. Eva waved and said, "Hi!"
"Mom??? Why didn't you knock?"
"The better question would be why didn't you lock? You see how hard it is to lock the door when you're excited!" Eva shrugged.
"That's not important here! Eva, run!" Brenna pushed her away.
"Eva, if you run, you're dead! Get dressed you two and get to my room!" Ophelia closed the door behind and left.
"Why is it getting worse every single time?" Brenna pressed her pillow against her face and leaned back first on her bed.
"I see this as a positive improvement." Eva smirked. Brenna removed the pillow and looked at Eva. "I think I can seduce her!"
"Ew...I'm already letting my brother fuck you. Mom is off limits!"
"Come on, Brenna! Just look at that milf! She's everything I want in a mature woman."
"She's married for God's sake. Do you think you can seduce her and destroy my parents' marriage?"
"Wow...I forgot about your dad's existence. I'm a bad friend, aren't I?"
"No, you are the best, Eva! Let's just go see my mom before she gets any ideas of punishments from old times!" They both got out of bed and got dressed.
_____________
Brenna opened the door to see the back of her mother. Then she noticed Eva drooling next to her after seeing Ophelia's ass. Brenna bumped her elbow getting Eva's head out of the gutter. Brenna scratched her head trying to find an excuse. "Mom, we're sorry for what happened!"
"Do you have any idea how Sterling would feel if he saw what you two just did?" Ophelia turned around sending daggers with her eyes. "Brenna, she's dating your brother. Are you that horny to do such a thing to your brother?"
"Actually, Sterling already knows, Ophelia!" Eva blurted it out which put Brenna in an even tougher situation.
"What the fuck Eva!!! Don't you have a filter?" Brenna yelled at her.
Ophelia was confused by the situation. "So, Sterling knows? You two are sharing Eva?" Brenna and Eva looked at each other and nodded in synchrony. "So, you're not cheating on my son?"
"Well, me and Sterling agreed on something, so he's cool with me fooling around with my friends...which includes Brenna!" Eva said it proudly which made Ophelia sigh.
"And you're not troubled by the fact that your brother had been inside her multiple times?" Ophelia asked her daughter.
"Ew, Mom! Stop phrasing it that way! It's weird hearing you say stuff like this."
"I take that as a yes. You two shouldn't be fooling around with a door wide open. I'm okay with your arrangement as long as you're not hurting, Sterling!" Ophelia calmed down with a sound of relief. Brenna and Eva left the room, thinking about what happened.
________________
Sterling was driving to Amber's house with a pouting Catherine looking outside by the window. "Do you want to talk about it?"
"..."
"You know, Sydney texted me asking why you were ignoring her texts! Do you want me to say something to her?"
"Please don't! I don't want her to think little of me."
"She wouldn't, you know that! Cathy, this is something serious and you have to talk about it. I'm not asking you, not just as your lover but as your elder brother who has the responsibility to put your needs before mine."
"Is that why you left?" Catherine said while avoiding her brother's gaze.
"You're still holding a grudge against me after everything we've been through."
"Sorry, that came out wrong! You see, I know that you won't leave me again. You promised me. It's just, that when that guy was in my room, I was wondering what could have been different if you were there."
"Cathy, I did warn you about it."
"Yeah, I was so stupid to think something supernatural like that could happen. Then again, my role model showed up to my birthday then you and I happened. It was like a miracle."
Sterling checked her state while pulling up his car inside the gate. "Cathy, you trusted that man at first but you didn't the second time. Why did you suspect him the second time?"
"Because he was being mean about you. He was saying this stuff about Hunter. I think that man was a voyeur who is into old and young porn."
"That's what you came up with as a reason?"
"Yeah! That makes sense, doesn't it?"
"Well, thanks for defending me though but you need to keep your anger in control. You're not a little girl anymore. You're a strong woman."
"Say the guy who put a fat ass through a table!"
"Hey, Kevin deserved it!"
"So, did the mystery voyeur!" Catherine was right. Sterling knew who that was. Hunter was trying to one-up on him before leaving. Sterling was in contact with Detective Wilson who was in charge of searching where Hunter was. Sterling already had some plans ready to be executed. So, revealing the truth about Hunter to anyone else would only ruin his bug revenge scheme.
_______________
Sterling knocked on the door. He heard footsteps approaching the door as it swung open to reveal Amber. "Hey, you two!"
"Hello, Amber! I'm here to drop Catherine!"
"What? You're not joining us? Your mom told my mom that you're joining."
"Is that what she meant? Okay, I can join you. If you don't mind, I need to make a call."
"Okay, join us in the living room after your call!" Amber grabbed Catherine's wrist and brought her inside.
Sterling took his phone out. "Hey!"
[What do you want?]
"Can you take a look out for Mom?"
[You're not coming home?]
"No..!"
[I wanted to tell you something.]
"Huh, is it about us?"
[Forget it! FYI, Mom caught me and Eva so I told her you and I are sharing her]
"What? What the hell, Brenna?"
[I'm hanging up. Bye!]
"Wait...what happened" She hung up on him as Sterling looked confused. 'One more thing I should deal with.' He turned around and went inside.
________________
Sterling entered the living room and met Casipan and Kumiko. "Hi!"
"Look at this young man! I hope you remember me!" Caspian extended his hand for a handshake.
"What are you blabbering, Caspian? He had never met you before." Kumiko crossed her arms.
"I didn't. He's Rebecca's brother, right?"
"He's Catherine's brother and Rebecca doesn't have a brother. You are really embarrassing yourself in front of our guests."
Sterling shook his hand and said, "It's nice to finally meet you, sir! I'm Sterling Johnson, Catherine's brother."
"Oh, now I remember. You're the one who wants to date my little Amber."
"Well..."
"Don't worry, I'm not a tough dad. As long as she is in good care, I'm not worried about her well-being. My wife approved it so I trust her judgement."
"Oh, thank you Mr Twistleton! I really appreciate your generosity."
"Kumiko, I like this kid. Then let's go to the party!"
"You two are going out?"
"We decided to attend a party so that Amber can spend some time with her friends. Will you be staying here too?" Kumiko asked Sterling.
"I'm going to hang out for a while. I'll leave afterwards and I'll come tomorrow morning to pick up Catherine."
"A protective brother, I see! I'll meet you tomorrow then, Sterling!" Caspian and Kumiko left the living room. Sterling scratched his head and went upstairs to meet the girls.
_______________
Back at the Johnsons household, Brenna built up some courage after what happened and went to check on her mother. Before she could knock on the door, she heard weeping noises coming out of the room. 'Is she crying?' Her knuckle was shaking. 'What should I do? She's crying. I have to help her but it's too much for me.' She retreated her hand and went downstairs.
She looked at her phone. She wanted to call her brother. 'Why am I taking my anger on him? I have to accept the fact that this is what it is. He has a personal life and so am I. I can't always depend on him. I should be mature enough to deal with it on my own. Mom needs some comfort but...' She rested her head back on the sofa looking at the ceiling.
________________
Inside Amber's room, Rebecca, Amber and Catherine were discussing what Catherine was going through. Sterling entered the room. "Hey, girls! Amber's parents just left."
"Cool, we can finally do something fun!" Amber was excited. She pulled out a beer from her cooler and gave it to Catherine. "Come on! Drink it!" Catherine exchanged looks between her and Sterling.
"Why are you looking at me?" Sterling asked.
"I don't handle alcohol very much so I always ask mom for permission in case I go down. But Mom put you in charge."
"Catherine, Mom didn't put me in charge. You're free to do whatever you want. This is a safe environment. I don't think anyone would take advantage of you here in Amber's place."
"Except Rebecca!" Amber intervened.
"What? Why me?"
"Because you keep losing to her in every game we played."
"Yeah. Why would you think I would take advantage of Catherine because of that? If I were to take advantage of someone, I'd probably choose you. You've been at my throat ever since I came back from the farm."
"Ok...aaay! I see that there are tensions between you two. Why don't we all drink and talk about these issues?" Sterling asked.
_______________
Fifteen minutes later, Catherine was lying on Amber's lap, singing a song. "I should have listened to her when she said she didn't handle alcohol that well." Sterling put his bottle down.
"I know, right? I've never seen her act this way. At least, she's no longer upset." Amber was inches close to Sterling. Alcohol made her mind cloud, she forgot why she had an audience.
"Where are you *hic* going, Amber?" Catherine got up and grabbed Amber's cheek. "You're pretty!" Without a warning, she planted her lips onto her. She completely made out with her which startled Rebecca.
"Is it that common during sleepovers?" Sterling asked Rebecca pointing at them while averting his eyes even though deep down he wanted to watch it. But he had to play the part in front of Rebecca and Amber.
"I was told that it is common for girls to end up kissing during sleepovers but this is the first time I've seen one," Rebecca said as she sipped her bottle. Meanwhile, Catherine dropped to the floor. Amber was furious that a kiss was stolen from her but she was excited due to the effects of the alcohol.
"What the fuck Catherine?" Amber yelled at her and yanked her. She then looked at Sterling and jumped on him. "I'm horny because of your little sis! You're going to fuck me!"